Background — abstract and introduction
Revised abstract and submitted manuscript · April 3, 2026
Abstract (revised)
Circular economy policies are promoted as a pathway to reduce material throughput, emissions and resource use, yet their macroeconomic and cross-border effects depend on the demand channels and production networks they alter. We use a two-region ecological macroeconomic model that combines multi-regional input–output accounting with stock–flow consistent dynamics, calibrated on 2011 EXIOBASE data. Twelve primary-to-secondary substitutions are tested in EU/Rest-of-World and North/South regional setups under four external closures, each against its own high-finance baseline. The reported results are medium-run means over one cycle of the baseline accelerator, \(t=79\ldots100\). Household food substitution engages a large consumption channel but reduces EU employment and raises water use. Intermediate energy substitution gives the largest EU emission reduction and expands EU value added, while lowering the EU wage share; intermediate metals substitution cuts material extraction and expands EU activity while raising emissions. The cross-border value-added sign categories change with the regional setup and closure, and multivariate clustering does not establish a two-mode transmission taxonomy. Ecological improvement, expansion and a rising wage share coincide in the intervening region in one of 96 runs, under a fiscal closure. The EU draws, net, on the Rest of the World for a large share of the emissions, materials, land and water embodied in its final demand; the interventions barely move that balance, and intermediate energy substitution raises the embodied emissions it draws. The results therefore support channel-specific ecological and distributional trade-offs rather than a universal ranking. They are not long-run results: extended to \(t=200\) under the gold closure, the value-added response of at least one region has the opposite sign over \(t=179\ldots200\) in 21 of the 24 scenario × setup runs, mainly because of a finance premium on scenario-induced liabilities.
Abstract (submitted)
Submitted (2026-04-03).
Circular economy policies are promoted as a pathway to reduce material throughput, emissions, and resource use. Yet, their macroeconomic and transnational effects remain poorly understood. This paper develops a two-region ecological macroeconomic model that integrates multi-regional input–output structure with stock–flow consistent dynamics, calibrated for the European Union (EU) and the Rest of the World (RoW). The study analyses circular economy transitions in the context of EU-RoW ecologically unequal exchange through a channel-based framework, distinguishing between interventions operating via final demand, intermediate production, and investment. Results show that the effectiveness of circular economy policies depends on the scale and structure of the demand channels they target. Final-demand interventions are impactful only when they engage dominant sectoral channels (such as household consumption in food or government procurement in plastics), while intermediate-production restructuring delivers stronger ecological improvements, but at the cost of modest contractions in output and employment. This pattern, however, is not uniform: in metals, circular production reduces material use and expands economic activity while increasing emissions due to higher upstream energy intensity. By contrast, energy restructuring delivers the largest emission reductions due to both scale and intensity differentials. Finally, investment-driven transitions can generate large macroeconomic effects but may also entail adverse environmental outcomes under current technological conditions. Overall, the analysis shows that circular economy transitions generate systematic transnational trade-offs across regions, sectors, and policy channels. Effective policy therefore requires coordinated, channel-specific strategies that align circularity with decarbonisation, macroeconomic stabilisation, and international equity.
Submitted-paper context: The abstract and introduction retain the April 3 manuscript’s framing, with the Barrie reference corrected to the verified 2024 report. Their model descriptions and results refer to the submitted specification; current equations, closure experiments and analyses are available in the site navigation.
Introduction
The transition to sustainability is nowadays understood to go beyond the energy transition, requiring the adoption of circular-economy (CE) strategies that seek to reduce material throughput, as well as emissions, increasing efficiency in resource use (Geissdoerfer et al., 2017; Korhonen et al., 2018). A global stocktake identifies 75 national circular-economy calls to action, roadmaps and operational strategies, comprising 2,882 policy actions, while finding that social equity and international coordination are often neglected (Barrie et al., 2024). Results from most academic studies, conducting ex-ante analysis, have projected positive environmental and socio-economic impacts of the adoption of CE strategies, especially at the national or regional level (Aguilar-Hernandez et al., 2018; Fevereiro et al., 2025).
Yet, the effects of a circular transition cannot be assessed only in the country where policy is legislated. This is because supply chains, trade relations, and financial hierarchies connect countries and regions asymmetrically. This implies that policies designed for cleaner production and consumption in advanced economies may reallocate costs, demand pressures, and ecological burdens across countries rather than resolve them globally (Wiedmann et al., 2015; Dorninger et al., 2021). Moreover, recent research suggests that circularity and decarbonisation do not necessarily move together, since circular initiatives can generate energy-intensive processes, upstream emission increases, or burden-shifting across supply chains when they are not coordinated with broader net-zero strategies (Arranz et al., 2026).
Circular transitions occur within a global economy that is characterised by unequal ecological exchange, persistent structural asymmetries, and monetary and financial constraints (Hornborg, 2009; Hickel et al., 2022). The literature on ecologically unequal exchange shows that environmental improvements in high-income economies are typically associated with the externalisation of extraction, energy use, labour, and waste-intensive production through trade and global value chains (Wiedmann et al., 2015; Dorninger et al., 2021). This implies that CE policies cannot be assessed only using domestic indicators of efficiency or decarbonisation. Ecological gains in the centre might actually rely on the continued ecological appropriation of labour, land, energy, and materials from the periphery (Lenzen et al., 2012; Hickel et al., 2022). Additionally, research on degrowth and global dependency indicates that ecological transition is driven by a “twin problem”: the material excesses of the Global North make transformation necessary, while North–South dependencies constrain the policy space and development opportunities of the Global South (Gräbner-Radkowitsch and Strunk, 2023; Hickel, 2020).
In this context, ecological macroeconomic modelling offers a complementary perspective: climate policies introduced in the centre may generate contractionary pressures, external imbalances, and financial instability in the periphery, especially when policy coordination is weak and structural asymmetries remain unchanged (Althouse et al., 2020; Campiglio et al., 2018). For example, Fevereiro and Lowe (2025) show that different types of green transition strategies in the Global North lead to lower GDP and employment and worsening trade balances in the Global South under existing patterns of specialisation. Furthermore, the current international monetary and financial system limits the ability of many countries in the Global South to absorb shocks, sustain green investment, or pursue autonomous transition strategies, even where “green” finance is available (Svartzman and Althouse, 2020; Volz et al., 2015).
Yet CE policy is often analyzed from technical or managerial perspectives that emphasize recycling, efficiency, product-life extension, or demand shifts (Kirchherr et al., 2017; Geissdoerfer et al., 2017). Less attention is paid to the structural relations through which environmental benefits and socio-economic costs are distributed internationally, and to the fact that different CE channels do not have the same macroeconomic or ecological effects. We argue, therefore, that the question is not whether circular-economy practices reduce emissions or material extraction in isolation, but under what conditions they do so, for whom, through which demand and production channels, and with what distributional consequences across regions. Specifically, the ecological, social and macroeconomic effectiveness of CE policies in the context of ecologically unequal exchange is contingent on whether they operate through final demand, intermediate production, or investment dynamics — a channel-based distinction that existing open-economy CE analyses have not systematically pursued.
Addressing such complex research gaps requires a framework that simultaneously tracks sector-level demand channels, cross-border material and financial flows, macroeconomic dynamics, and ecological extensions — a combination that existing approaches provide only partially. Static multi-regional IO models capture cross-border ecological footprints but are silent on income distribution, financial balances, and demand-driven contractions (Wiedmann et al., 2015; Dorninger et al., 2021). Ecological stock-flow consistent models capture macro-financial dynamics and distributional effects but aggregate production into representative sectors, making it impossible to distinguish demand channels or CE substitution pathways (Dafermos et al., 2018; Carnevali et al., 2019). Two-region SFC models without IO structure capture cross-regional financial asymmetries but cannot distinguish material types or the channel architecture that governs policy leverage (Althouse et al., 2020; Fevereiro and Lowe, 2025).
We address this gap through a two-region ecological macroeconomic model, which combines all four dimensions in the global context of the transition to a circular economy, combining multi-regional input–output structure and stock–flow consistent dynamics, calibrated for the European Union and the Rest of the World using EXIOBASE 2011 data and 54 industries covering ten basic materials — food, energy, wood, plastics, pulp, paper, metals, glass, cement, and construction — each disaggregated into a primary (virgin, resource-intensive) and a secondary (resource-efficient) production sector. By combining ecological and input-output extensions with a macro-financial two-region framework, the model allows us to analyse complex circular-economy scenarios as structurally differentiated demand transition regimes rather than isolated technical shocks (Leontief, 1941; Aguilar-Hernandez et al., 2018; Fevereiro et al., 2025).
We simulate 14 circular economy transition scenarios, each targeting a different primary-to-secondary substitution pathway and varying systematically by demand channel (final demand, intermediate production, investment) and institutional sectors (households, government, firms). Model simulations show how dynamic sector-level changes in final demand, intermediate production, and sectoral expansion affect value added, employment, income distribution, fiscal and current-account balances, emissions, and material extraction domestically and across borders. In doing so, we examine how circular-economy policies generate transnational socio-ecological trade-offs and cross-regional macro-financial asymmetries.
Our results identify three structural patterns. First, the effectiveness of CE policy depends on the scale of the demand channel engaged: household food transitions generate the largest final-demand employment and material effects, government procurement is the primary CE lever for plastics, and consumer energy behaviour is structurally secondary to industrial procurement as a climate instrument. Second, intermediate production restructuring delivers stronger ecological gains — energy restructuring is the highest-leverage scenario in both emissions and primary material extraction — but generates modest macroeconomic contractions; metals is the exception, expanding output while reducing material throughput, yet producing a structural emissions rebound through the higher fossil-electricity intensity of secondary steel production. Third, most CE scenarios are distributionally regressive along two simultaneous dimensions: within the EU, mark-up pricing transfers the output contraction disproportionately to the wage bill; across borders, the same transitions deteriorate fiscal positions in the periphery and — in the energy scenario — generate a sustained rise in peripheral public debt as fossil export revenues permanently collapse.
Across the full scenario set, four distinct cross-border transmission patterns emerge — symmetric material contraction, competitive displacement, fossil-import collapse, and production leakage — trade-offs that are structurally embedded in the global production system and invisible to single-region frameworks. In symmetric contraction, both regions contract proportionally as secondary sectors require fewer intermediate inputs per unit of output, generating shared ecological gains at a shared macroeconomic cost. In competitive displacement, EU secondary-sector expansion directly substitutes for RoW primary exports, compressing peripheral output and employment while the core captures the productivity gain. In fossil-import collapse, the EU energy transition permanently eliminates fossil-fuel export revenues on which peripheral fiscal systems depend, generating a sustained rise in RoW public debt that deepens sovereign vulnerabilities already associated with financialised peripherality. In production leakage, the higher import content of secondary sectors means that part of the CE demand shift flows back to RoW as intermediate inputs, creating a partial positive spillover that partially offsets — but does not reverse — the core’s material savings. Each pattern implies a distinct distributional settlement between centre and periphery, and the policy implications differ accordingly.
This paper contributes to the ecological economics literature in three ways. First, it integrates circular-economy analysis with ecological macroeconomics in an open-economy, multi-regional framework. Second, it introduces a channel-based perspective that distinguishes between final-demand, intermediate-production, and investment-driven transition pathways. Third, it demonstrates that circular-economy policies generate systematic transnational trade-offs structurally embedded in the global production system. The findings suggest that an effective and just transition requires channel-specific, coordinated policy that simultaneously addresses circularity, decarbonisation, and the international asymmetries through which ecological costs are displaced.
Following this introduction, Section 1 provides an overview of the model; Section 2 describes the multi-regional input-output structure of demand; Section 3 presents the scenarios; Section 4 discusses the simulation results and their policy implications; and Section 5 provides conclusions and avenues for further research.
References
Aguilar-Hernandez, G. A., Sigüenza-Sanchez, C. P., Donati, F., Rodrigues, J. F. D., Tukker, A. (2018). Assessing circularity interventions: A review of MRIO-based studies. Journal of Economic Structures, 8(1), 1–16.
Althouse, J., Guarini, G., Porcile, G. (2020). Ecological macroeconomics in the open economy: Sustainability, unequal exchange and policy coordination in a center–periphery model. Ecological Economics, 172, 106628.
Arranz, C.F.A., Arroyabe, M.F., Demirel, P., Kesidou, E., Panwar, R., Pinkse, J., 2026. Reconciling circular economy and net zero: Firm capabilities to resolve sustainability tensions. British Journal of Management, 00, e70061.
Barrie, J., Salminen, I., Schröder, P., Stucki, J. (2024). National circular economy roadmaps: A global stocktake for 2024. United Nations Industrial Development Organization and Chatham House. https://www.unido.org/sites/default/files/unido-publications/2024-05/UNIDO_National%20circular%20economy%20roadmaps_v07.pdf
Berg, M., Hartley, B., Richters, O. (2015). A stock-flow consistent input-output model with applications to energy price shocks, interest rates, and heat emissions. New Journal of Physics, 17(1), 015011.
Bimpizas-Pinis, M., De Boer, B., Genovese, A., Jabbour, C.J.C., Khan, S.A.R. (2023). A systematic literature review on the environmental impacts of transitioning towards a circular economy. Journal of Cleaner Production, 405, 137056.
Campiglio, E., Dafermos, Y., Monnin, P., Ryan-Collins, J., Schotten, G., Tanaka, M., 2018. Climate change challenges for central banks and financial regulators. Nature Climate Change, 8(6), 462–468.
Carnevali, E., Deleidi, M., Pariboni, R., Veronese Passarella, M. (2019). Cross-border financial flows and global warming in a two-area ecological SFC model. Socio-Economic Review, 17(3), 617–648.
Carnevali, E., Deleidi, M., Pariboni, R., Veronese Passarella, M. (2020). A dynamic stock-flow consistent model with a full recovery of waste and a net-zero emissions target. Review of Political Economy, 32(4), 527–552.
Carnevali, E., Deleidi, M., Pariboni, R., Veronese Passarella, M. (2023). SFC models and the ecological transition. Metroeconomica, 74(4), 862–905.
Caverzasi, E., Godin, A. (2015). Post-Keynesian stock-flow-consistent modelling: a survey. Cambridge Journal of Economics, 39(1), 157–187.
Dafermos, Y., Nikolaidi, M., Galanis, G. (2017). A stock-flow-fund ecological macroeconomic model. Ecological Economics, 131, 191–207.
Dafermos, Y., Nikolaidi, M., Galanis, G. (2018). Climate change, financial stability and monetary policy. Ecological Economics, 152, 219–234.
De Boer, B. F., Rietveld, E., Rodrigues, J. F., Tukker, A. (2021). Global environmental and socio-economic impacts of a transition to a circular economy in metal and electrical products: A Dutch case study. Journal of Industrial Ecology, 25(5), 1264–1271.
Di Domenico, L., Barbieri Góes, M. C., Gallo, E. (2024). Distribution, capital intensity and public debt-to-GDP ratio: an input output-stock flow consistent model. Economia Politica, 41(2), 395–416.
Dorninger, C., Hornborg, A., Abson, D. J., von Wehrden, H., Schaffartzik, A., Giljum, S., Engler, J.-O., Feller, R. L., Hubacek, K., Wieland, H. (2021). Global patterns of ecologically unequal exchange: Implications for sustainability in the 21st century. Ecological Economics, 179, 106824.
Fevereiro, J.B.R.T., Kaltenbrunner, A., Kesidou, E., Veronese Passarella, M. (2023). A two-area ecological input-output stock-flow consistent model for circular economy analysis. Working Paper, University of Leeds.
Fevereiro, J.B.R.T., Lowe, B.H. (2025). Macroeconomic implications for the Global South of a green transition in the Global North. Ecological Economics, 237, 108691.
Geissdoerfer, M., Savaget, P., Bocken, N.M.P., Hultink, E.J., 2017. The circular economy – A new sustainability paradigm? Journal of Cleaner Production, 143, 757–768.
Godley, W., Lavoie, M. (2007). Monetary Economics: An Integrated Approach to Credit, Money, Income, Production and Wealth. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke.
Gräbner-Radkowitsch, C., Strunk, B. (2023). Degrowth and the Global South: The twin problem of global dependencies. Ecological Economics, 213, 107946.
Hardt, L., O’Neill, D. W. (2017). Ecological macroeconomic models: assessing current developments. Ecological Economics, 134, 198–211.
Hickel, J., 2020. Quantifying national responsibility for climate breakdown: an equality-based attribution approach for carbon dioxide emissions in excess of the planetary boundary. The Lancet Planetary Health, 4(9), e399–e404.
Hickel, J., Dorninger, C., Wieland, H., Suwandi, I., 2022. Imperialist appropriation in the world economy: drain from the Global South through unequal exchange, 1990–2015. Global Environmental Change, 73, 102467.
Hornborg, A., 2009. Zero-sum world: challenges in conceptualizing environmental load displacement and ecologically unequal exchange in the world-system. International Journal of Comparative Sociology, 50(3–4), 237–262.
Jackson, A., Jackson, T. (2025). Macroeconomic, sectoral and financial dynamics in energy transitions: a stock-flow consistent, input-output approach. Ecological Economics, 230, 108507.
Kirchherr, J., Reike, D., Hekkert, M., 2017. Conceptualizing the circular economy: an analysis of 114 definitions. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 127, 221–232.
Korhonen, J., Honkasalo, A., Seppälä, J., 2018. Circular economy: the concept and its limitations. Ecological Economics, 143, 37–46.
Lenzen, M., Moran, D., Kanemoto, K., Geschke, A., 2012. Mapping the structure of the world economy. Environmental Science & Technology, 46(15), 8374–8381.
Leontief, W. (1936). Quantitative input-output relations in the economic system of the United States. Review of Economics and Statistics, 18(3), 105–125.
Leontief, W. (1941). The Structure of American Economy, 1919–1929. Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
Nikiforos, M., Zezza, G. (2017). Stock-flow consistent macroeconomic models: a survey. Journal of Economic Surveys, 31(5), 1204–1239.
Pettena, M., Raberto, M. (2025). Energy transition and structural change: a calibrated stock-flow consistent input-output model. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, online.
Pollitt, H., Mercure, J.-F., 2018. The role of money and the financial sector in energy-economy models used for assessing climate and energy policy. Climate Policy, 18(2), 184–197.
Svartzman, R., Althouse, J. (2020). Greening the international monetary system? Not without addressing the political ecology of global imbalances. Review of International Political Economy, 28(4), 966–989.
Thomsen, S. F., Raza, H., Byrialsen, M. R. (2025). An assessment of carbon taxation policies: the case of Denmark. Ecological Economics, 238, 108741.
Valdecantos, S., Valentini, S. (2017). Financialization and capital accumulation dynamics in a post-Keynesian input-output macro model. Working Paper, Universidad Nacional de General Sarmiento.
Veronese Passarella, M. (2023). Technical change and the monetary circuit: an input-output stock-flow consistent dynamic model. Quaderni del Dipartimento di Economia Politica e Statistica — Università di Siena, n. 903.
Veronese Passarella, M. (2025). Destabilizing a stable economy: Minsky meets Graziani’s monetary circuit. International Journal of Political Economy, 54(3), 338–355.
Volz, U., Böhnke, J., Knierim, L., Richert, K., Röber, G.-M., Eidt, V. (2015). Financing the Green Transformation: How to Make Green Finance Work in Indonesia. Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke.
Wiedmann, T. O., Schandl, H., Lenzen, M., Moran, D., Suh, S., West, J., Kanemoto, K. (2015). The material footprint of nations. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 112(20), 6271–6276.